BlackHorse Properties Real Estate Blog

April 28, 2022

Top Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Property Manager

Property management is a complicated, fast-paced business, so it’s important to find the right property manager for you and your commercial or residential property. Some qualities to look for in a potential property manager may be:

A positive attitude
Communicative
Detail oriented
Organized
Honest
Passionate about real estate

Questions To Ask: 

What services do you offer your clients? 
The goal is to find a property management company that can market, lease, and manage your property. It’s important to make sure this company can provide top-notch maintenance services, conduct inspections, and administer in-depth background checks.

What experience does your company owner have in managing rentals?
If the company owner has never managed a rental, it’s possible that their company will lack the ability to effectively help you with your investment property.

How do you determine the rent for each property?
The right property manager should be able to complete a comparable market analysis of all other available listings near your property in order to determine how much to charge for rent, with the addition of factoring in the unique aspects of your rental property, like a pool or an upgraded kitchen.

Are you an active real estate investor?
The company’s leadership should be investing in the real estate market themselves. If they do not understand investment in your market, then they may not be able to give you the service you require.

What are the management fees?
It’s important to understand your average monthly fee. Some companies may offer a flat rate, and others will offer a rate based on the rent amount.

Do I still pay when the property is vacant?
If you’re dealing with a flat rate, then you will likely still be charged even when your unit is vacant. If this doesn’t work for you, let your candidate(s) know.

Are there any miscellaneous fees?
If the deal is too good to be true, then it may be just that. You don’t want to find yourself in a situation where you’ve signed with a company just for them to charge you extra fees along the way.

Do you offer direct deposit for your owners?
If you prefer to get payment by check, then that’s perfectly fine. However, if you’d like the option to have payment directly deposited in your account, be sure to ask the candidate about this option.

How do you collect rent from tenants?
Many property managers allow tenants to pay by check, money order, or online. If you have a preference, be sure to make that clear with the candidate and ask how they choose to collect rent.

Do you conduct property inspections? 
Most property managers do conduct inspections and require a small fee. It ensures that management will catch problems before they turn into major issues.

How do you market properties? 
You want to find a property manager who advertises properties through a variety of channels to give your rental the best possible chance of staying occupied, as well as someone who can write an excellent property description that captures the value of your rental.

How long are your properties typically vacant?
The average vacancy time after a property is ready to be rented should be about two to four weeks. Any longer than this suggests the property manager may be struggling to find tenants.

What are your income and screening requirements for applicants?
It’s important for you and your property manager to agree on the standards necessary to rent your property. For instance, many landlords and property managers agree that the tenant(s) must make three-times the rent for their application to be approved, among other reasonable requirements. Look for a property manager who will ask the right questions during the screening process.

Do I have any control over the lease agreement? Y
you want to have some input about the lease agreement if there are certain rules or regulations that are important to you. But remember that the right property manager should be able to provide a lease that’s tailored to you and your property.

Will I get updates on my properties? 
Your properties are your investment, so you’ll want proper updates on them to see if there have been changes in the market, to the quality of your rental, or in tenancy.
© All rights reserved

By Blackhorsevt.com

By Chris Willett • October 5, 2026
Learn how Vermont multifamily property owners can improve occupancy, reduce tenant turnover, and increase retention through better leasing, maintenance, communication, and property management.
By Chris Willett • September 26, 2026
Should you rent your Mount Snow property short-term or for the season? Compare income potential, occupancy, management, costs, risks, and flexibility.
By Chris Willett • September 26, 2026
Explore the 2026 apartment rental market in Bennington and Brattleboro, Vermont, and Pittsfield, Massachusetts, including current rents, market trends, vacancy factors, and what property owners should know.
By Chris Willett • September 26, 2026
Learn how to set seasonal rental rates near Mount Snow, Vermont. Understand ski-season pricing, summer and fall demand, operating costs, and what owners should consider.
By Chris Willett • September 26, 2026
Planning to rent a vacation home in Wilmington, VT in 2027? Explore current rental market data, seasonal demand, pricing, competition, regulations, and key considerations for owners.
By Chris Willett • September 23, 2026
Delaying rental property repairs may save money today but cost more later. Learn how deferred maintenance can affect your property's expenses, tenants, and long-term value.
By Chris Willett • September 23, 2026
Is your rental property constantly dealing with the same repairs? Learn why recurring problems happen and how addressing the root cause can reduce costs and tenant complaints.
By Chris Willett • September 19, 2026
How to Know When a Rental Property Needs More Than Routine Maintenance
By Chris Willett • September 19, 2026
Should You Renovate a Rental Property to Increase Its Income?
By Chris Willett • September 19, 2026
What Expenses Are Eating Into My Rental Property Income?